Why Genuine Mindfulness Can Be Discomforting at Times
In a society perpetually pursuing tranquility and peace, mindfulness is frequently seen as a remedy for turmoil—a refuge where calmness is promised to those who are prepared to shut their eyes and breathe deeply. However, for those who genuinely engage in the practice, an unexpected realization surfaces: authentic mindfulness is not always serene. In fact, it can frequently be unsettling.
This unsettling aspect of mindfulness is not a defect in the practice; it’s an essential component of awakening to reality. Mindfulness is not a mechanism for escaping your experience. It’s an invitation to immerse yourself completely in it, regardless of how chaotic, emotional, or messy it may become.
Let’s examine why genuine mindfulness can feel uncomfortable at times, and why that’s actually a sign that you are on the right path.
The Mirage of Calm vs. True Presence
You find yourself sitting with your eyes closed and your breath steady. The surface of your mind may appear calm, akin to a tranquil pond. Yet, beneath that calmness, subtle narratives often linger:
– “I’m finally getting this right.”
– “I feel significantly more mindful today.”
– “I’ve mastered this better than those around me.”
These thoughts feel affirming. However, here’s the twist: they do not represent presence. They are your mind donning a costume, pretending to be mindful while clinging to ego-driven tales. Paradoxically, the more we pursue the sensation of being mindful, the further we stray from genuine awareness.
Authentic mindfulness does not guarantee a pleasurable experience. It demands radical honesty. It connects us with the present moment as it exists, not as we wish it to be.
The Performance Trap: When Mindfulness Turns into Proof of Skill
Our society celebrates productivity, mastery, and the exhibition of skill. Consequently, it’s tempting to view mindfulness as something to “accomplish” or perform. This is what might occur:
– You find yourself comparing your mindfulness to others.
– You feel a sense of achievement after a meditation session.
– You take pride in labeling yourself as a calm, composed person.
However, when mindfulness becomes a performance, its authenticity diminishes. You start observing your own mindfulness, judging the experience instead of fully inhabiting it.
It’s akin to a musician so caught up in hitting the right notes that they cease to feel the music. Or a public speaker so focused on appearing confident that they lose touch with genuine engagement.
Mindfulness is not a show. It’s an intimate, unfiltered encounter with yourself. There’s no audience.
The False Calm: Using Mindfulness to Evade Emotions
One of the most commonly misinterpreted aspects of mindfulness is emotional bypassing. You might’ve heard these phrases:
– “Just let it go.”
– “Remain calm.”
– “I shouldn’t feel this way.”
These statements appear mindful, don’t they? Yet in some instances, they conceal a subtle avoidance—a reluctance to confront discomfort, anger, grief, or fear.
Authentic mindfulness isn’t about dulling challenging emotions. It’s about approaching them with curiosity.
Picture yourself meditating following a painful disagreement. You take some breaths and attempt to “be mindful.” However, instead of recognizing your anger, you suppress it with thoughts like, “I’m too spiritually evolved to feel anger.”
That’s not mindfulness. That’s denial, cloaked in a guise of spirituality.
Mindfulness involves recognizing the heat of emotion rising within your body, the tightness in your jaw, the chaos in your thoughts—and permitting it to exist, without immediately reacting or suppressing it.
The Ego of the “Mindful Person”
There’s one pitfall that few are willing to acknowledge: the identity trap. Initially, mindfulness feels personal; you meditate, you learn, you evolve. Yet, before long, you might find yourself donning “mindfulness” as a symbol:
– You suggest books to others.
– You remind friends to “be present.”
– You take pride in being the “calm one.”
This feels gratifying as it boosts ego—the very thing mindfulness seeks to dissolve. When mindfulness turns into part of your identity, it ceases to serve as awareness. The moment you assert, “I am mindful,” you risk stepping away from genuine presence and into self-praise.
Mindfulness is not a trait. It is not a commodity to flaunt. It is a continuous, moment-by-moment relationship with life that cannot be owned—only experienced.
Authentic Mindfulness Is Often Raw, Not Tranquil
Genuine mindfulness invites discomfort because it exposes truth. And truth—especially concerning oneself—is not always pleasant. When you truly pay attention, you begin to discern aspects your mind prefers to overlook:
– Anxiety hiding beneath the everyday routine.
– The pain stemming from unmet expectations.
– Your inclination to control outcomes.
– Old wounds masquerading as healed.
This isn’t suffering for its own purpose. It’s a vital aspect of becoming awakened.
As one Zen saying suggests, “To be truly awakened is to be in the now—and sometimes the now hurts.”
Traversing the Untamed Path
Mindfulness, in its purest form, is…